2009-11-03 13:03:02 In reply to Tinks (2009-11-03 12:56:51)

2009-11-03 14:03:36

Bit soon to condemn it, i know its a game movie, but it might survive...

---
I think i have stood in poo

2009-11-03 19:48:08

i think this has a far better chance of being good then most do tbh, it has a decent director and producer behind it, decent cast, and it's disney. trailer looked pretty cool too, no better or worse then POTC imo. should be good, whether it will top my current fave movie based on a game (silent hill) who knows.

2009-11-03 19:55:32

I think if it tops Silent Hill it's in a different way, at least for me. I really loved Gans' Silent Hill, but it was largely thanks to being faithful to the nature of a Silent Hill story and the look and feel of one. Prince of Persia can't get as much mileage out of simply evoking the feel of Sands of Time, it really has to be a great adventure movie, at which point the quality of the film itself becomes paramount.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that if PoP is good, it's automatically better as *a movie* than Silent Hill, and one that should appeal to anyone regardless of his or her familiarity with the game it's derived from.

I have actually been enthusiastic about this ever since I saw the workforce behind it and read that Disney's intention was to create a franchise to shoulder the Pirates mantle once that trilogy bowed out. Of course now it's evident that Pirates will stick around, and hopefully that hasn't impacted how much they'll be backing this one.

---
http://modeseven.blogspot.com | Dominic and Simon - dyanamic games blog duo!

2009-11-04 14:23:01

Your missing 1 thing about silent hill though Simon, it had sean bean in it.. and he was fucking awfull

oh and the fact it treats you like a idiot "look, ash" now shit ...

---
I think i have stood in poo